Mitchell Stephens, "Thinking 'Above the Stream,'" and:

• Jan Willis, Selections from Dreaming Me: An African American Woman's Buddhist Journey, "Decision Time: A 'Piece' or Peace?," "This, too, is Buddha's Mind," and "My Great Seal Retreat."
• Alexander Stille, "The Ganges' Next Life," and Jan Willis, Selections from Dreaming Me: An African American Woman's Buddhist Journey

For more assignment ideas involving this essay, please visit the Stephens link-o-mat.

Stephens and Willis: The Contemporary Media and the Implications for Selfhood

In your last assignment, I asked you to use Malcolm Gladwell's "The Power of Context: Bernie Goetz and the Rise and Fall of New York City Crime" and Jan Willis' "Selections from Dreaming Me: An African-American Woman's Spiritual Journey" to make an argument about the relationship between culture and the character of the individual. For your next paper I want you to take a closer look at this dynamic through the role that media plays in the contemporary world.

While Willis discusses her experience as an individual as a result of a choice between two conflicting cultures, in his essay "Thinking 'Above the Stream': New Philosophies," Mitchell Stephens assesses the ways in which the rise of visual media within our culture might be interacting with and changing how we think and communicate. What implications do contemporary media have for selfhood, and how might we respond to these implications?

Some questions to consider as you begin thinking about your paper: Is the change from a culture of the written word to a culture of the image that Stephens describes an indication of the transformation of the self or a cause of this transformation, or does it play some other role entirely? What does this process tell you in turn about the relation between media, culture, and selfhood on the whole? In her narrative, Willis travels from what we might call a "media-rich" culture to one with virtually no media at all. How do the changes she undergoes-or doesn't undergo-compare to the effects Stephens attributes to emergent visual media, and what might those two things suggest? How do "new video" and ancient religion each function within their respective cultures, and what is the relation between these functions? What conclusions can you draw from the visions of selfhood that each author presents?

For this essay, you are required to use at least three connections between Willis and Stephens to explore your position. If you feel it would help strengthen or develop your project, you may also discuss any of the authors we have previously discussed, although you are not required to do so.

Paul Benzon, Fall 2002

For the rest of this assignment sequence, see the Contemporary Visions of the Self, Character, & Tradition sequence.

Back to top

Stephens, Willis, and Stille: The Role of Tradition in the Contemporary World

In your last assignment, I asked you to use Jan Willis' "Selections from Dreaming Me: An African-American Woman's Spiritual Journey" and Mitchell Stephens' "Thinking 'Above the Stream': New Philosophies" to explore the relations and the potentials for action between media and selfhood. In his essay "The Ganges' Next Life," Alexander Stille explores Veer Bhadra Mishra's "complex double identity" (598) as both a manhant and an engineer, and the relationship of this identity to Mishra's attempt to save the Ganges River-a holy space of ancient Indian culture-through modern Western science.

What role should we assign to tradition in the contemporary world? Are traditional ways of thinking and living ultimately obsolete in the twenty-first century? If so, what does humanity lose in this transition, and what does it gain? How can we prepare ourselves for this change? If it is possible to sustain tradition within the contemporary world, is this always a desirable action, or are there losses involved as well? How might we achieve such a fusion most effectively? Can tradition provide a useful solution to the problems that the contemporary world poses? Is the relation between tradition and modernity different for cultures and individuals, or for different cultures? Should it be? Who should be given the power to make these decisions, and why?

For this paper, you are required to closely analyze relevant material from Stephens, Willis, and Stille at least three times each to explore your position-do not merely use their language to narrate your discussion. Your goal is to develop an independent project that is both engaged with and responsible to the perspectives and theories the authors present, but does not merely paraphrase their ideas or adopt them as your own, and to then explore that project through analysis of their perspectives and theories. In doing so, your paper should think creatively, connectively, and multiply.

If you feel it would help strengthen or develop your project, you may also discuss any of the others authors we have previously discussed, although you are not required to do so.

Paul Benzon, Fall 2002

For the rest of this assignment sequence, see the Contemporary Visions of the Self, Character, & Tradition sequence.

Back to top